Comment 14 for bug 141343

Revision history for this message
Shane Guillory (shane-rppl) wrote :

Some more feedback on this -

We are using Xubuntu Feisty and testing Hardy with a Kontron COMexpress CPU module with the RealTek 8111/8168 PCI-E adapter and had similar issues to other bugs reported here.

The manufacturer's r8168 driver (now at 8.005.00 as of 2008-01-29) for the 8111/8168 family(PCI id 10EC:8168) is generally much more robust than the r8169 driver in the kernel. With the mfg's r8168 (8168, that is, not 8169), I don't need to periodically restart the network any more, and it also fixed a major issue for us - the network adapter only worked if the adapter was physically connected at startup, the network would come up but not quite work right if connected after startup.

I don't know the process for this, but based on our experience, we would recommend that the Mfg's 8168 driver be incorporated into the kernel, and the [10EC:8168] pci id to be unassociated with the r8169 driver.

Thanks!