People spend more time on other Web sites than they do on yours. On practically every other Web site, the control for submitting text that you've entered is a button, usually without an icon. There's nothing obviously wrong or confusing about this pattern. Therefore, the control for submitting a comment on Launchpad should be a button, and it doesn't need an icon.
There's an interesting confusion in Launchpad about what a link with a "(+)" button does: (1) add something immediately (e.g. "Subscribe") or (2) request further input and then perform an action (e.g. "Subscribe someone else"). That confusion should be fixed separately, but adding a third meaning -- (3) submit information that you've already entered -- is a backward step.
People spend more time on other Web sites than they do on yours. On practically every other Web site, the control for submitting text that you've entered is a button, usually without an icon. There's nothing obviously wrong or confusing about this pattern. Therefore, the control for submitting a comment on Launchpad should be a button, and it doesn't need an icon.
There's an interesting confusion in Launchpad about what a link with a "(+)" button does: (1) add something immediately (e.g. "Subscribe") or (2) request further input and then perform an action (e.g. "Subscribe someone else"). That confusion should be fixed separately, but adding a third meaning -- (3) submit information that you've already entered -- is a backward step.